Back to Blog
Comparisons 2026-11-15 Premium Pet Supplies for Dogs & Cats - PetAmzStore 0 views

Pumpkin vs Peanut Butter Dog Biscuits: Which to Pick

Pumpkin vs Peanut Butter Dog Biscuits: Which to Pick

Compare two small-batch 1/2 lb dog biscuit treats: pumpkin for fiber-minded pups, peanut butter for protein and picky eaters. See the numbers and pick.

Two Biscuits, One Clear Split

Both Pumpkin Bits and Peanut Butter Bits come from the same small-batch oven-baked approach and both arrive as 1/2 lb bags of crunchy biscuits. The meaningful difference is what each recipe is built around: real pumpkin with oats and cinnamon, or real peanut butter with flour, oats, molasses, and vanilla.

That difference shows up in the guaranteed analysis. The pumpkin biscuits land at 10.5% minimum crude protein and 8.0% minimum crude fat, while the peanut butter biscuits list 12.18% minimum protein and 11.57% minimum fat. If you are choosing between them, those numbers plus your dog's reaction to rich or fiber-rich foods tell you most of what you need.

What Each Bag Actually Delivers

  • Homemade Dog Treats - Pumpkin Bits Dog Biscuits 1/2lb: Pumpkin Bits Dog Biscuits 1/2 lb: made with real pumpkin, whole oats, and cinnamon; guaranteed analysis shows crude protein min. 10.5%, crude fat min. 8.0%, crude fiber max. 1.8%, moisture max. 9.5%. The pumpkin and oat base plus the lower fat figure makes this the more fiber-forward, lighter biscuit of the two.
    Homemade Dog Treats - Pumpkin Bits Dog Biscuits 1/2lb
    Homemade Dog Treats - Pumpkin Bits Dog Biscuits 1/2lb
  • Homemade Dog Treats - Peanut Butter Bits Dog Biscuits 1/2lb: Peanut Butter Bits Dog Biscuits 1/2 lb: made with real peanut butter, flour, oats, molasses, and vanilla; guaranteed analysis shows crude protein min. 12.18%, crude fat min. 11.57%, crude fiber max. 1.29%, moisture max. 8.03%. Higher protein and higher fat mean a richer, more calorie-dense biscuit — useful for training rewards in small pieces, less ideal if you are watching weight.
    Homemade Dog Treats - Peanut Butter Bits Dog Biscuits 1/2lb
    Homemade Dog Treats - Peanut Butter Bits Dog Biscuits 1/2lb

Pumpkin Bits: For Fiber and Sensitive Stomachs

The pumpkin biscuit's selling point is digestive support. The listing describes pumpkin as rich in fiber and beta-carotene and positions the biscuit as gentle on digestion, even for picky eaters. The 1.8% maximum crude fiber is modest but real, and the 8.0% fat is lower than the peanut butter option.

That said, the listing does not provide calorie content per biscuit or a feeding amount. If your dog has a diagnosed sensitivity or is on a veterinary diet, treat this as a treat choice to discuss with your vet rather than a therapeutic food. The cinnamon is listed as an ingredient, so dogs with known reactions to it should skip this bag.

Peanut Butter Bits: For Protein and Picky Eaters

The peanut butter biscuit is the richer, more motivating reward. At 12.18% minimum protein and 11.57% minimum fat, it packs more of both than the pumpkin version, and the listing specifically calls out picky-eater approval and training use. Real peanut butter is the headline ingredient, with no artificial flavors listed.

The trade-off is exactly that richness: higher fat means more calories per bite, so if your dog is overweight or prone to pancreatitis, this is the bag to portion carefully or skip. The listing does not confirm whether the peanut butter is xylitol-free, so check the packaging or ask the seller before feeding if that is a concern for your household.

Side-by-Side: Where They Diverge

  • Guaranteed analysis: Pumpkin: 10.5% protein, 8.0% fat, 1.8% max fiber, 9.5% max moisture. Peanut butter: 12.18% protein, 11.57% fat, 1.29% max fiber, 8.03% max moisture.
  • Headline ingredients: Pumpkin: real pumpkin, whole oats, cinnamon, canola oil, eggs. Peanut butter: real peanut butter, flour, oats, molasses, vanilla, eggs.
  • Best fit: Pumpkin for dogs needing a lighter, fiber-leaning biscuit or those with sensitive digestion. Peanut butter for active dogs, training rewards, and fussy eaters who need a higher-value treat.
  • Watch out for: Pumpkin: cinnamon sensitivity, and no calorie data supplied. Peanut butter: higher fat, and xylitol status not confirmed in the supplied listing.

The 1/2 lb Bag and What It Means for Treating

Both bags are 1/2 lb, which is a practical size for testing whether your dog likes a flavor before committing to a larger bag. The biscuits are crunchy and described as small, bite-sized pieces for rewards, so they work well for training sessions where you need several quick treats.

Neither listing supplies a recommended daily treat amount or calorie count. A sensible approach is to treat them as a supplement to a complete diet and keep the total treat portion modest relative to your dog's daily food intake, adjusting based on your dog's weight and activity. If you are unsure, your vet can help you set a treat budget.

Related Articles

Customer Service
Home
Products
Cart
Profile